Phegley doubled in the third and then homered in the fifth as a major part of the five-hit attack against Cleveland starter Josh Tomlin. Phegley appears to be in a battle for the backup catcher spot behind Flowers, and did nothing to hurt his cause by guiding Dylan Axelrod through three scoreless innings.
Tomlin stands in a roster battle of his own, competing with Carlos Carrasco for the fifth spot in the Indians' rotation. The right-hander retired the first eight hitters before yielding Phegley's double in the third. The game was scoreless until the fifth when Conor Gillaspie went deep with two outs and Phegley followed.
"That pitch to Gillaspie, I was trying to go in there, trying to cut the ball in there. And he did a good job of dropping the head on it and hit it for a home run," Tomlin said. "The curveball to Phegley just caught too much plate. I thought it was a little bit up. Just didn't get it where I wanted to. I was trying to get a little more of a chase pitch, and it just stayed in the zone and he put a pretty good swing on it."
Over five innings of work, Tomlin fanned five and didn't issue a walk.
Erik Johnson, who was scheduled to throw Friday, was moved to a Minor League contest so as not to face the Indians. Axelrod yielded two hits and two walks in his place.
"I always feel like I'm the guy who has to prove himself," Axelrod said. "So in that regard, it's the same sort of thing. I guess even now, I have a little more of the chip on my shoulder or something. I know I have to do the same thing I've always done and work real hard."
Cleveland scored a run in the seventh off of Jake Petricka on a David Cooper double, a groundout and a passed ball. Cooper then tied the game in the eighth with a bases-loaded sacrifice fly.
Up next: After two straight games against American League Central rivals, the Tribe will head back to Goodyear Ballpark on Saturday to take on the visiting D-backs. It'll be a bullpen game for the pitching staff, with right-hander Frank Herrmann making his second Cactus League appearance. Vinnie Pestano, John Axford and Josh Outman are also scheduled to throw. The game will be broadcast live at 4:05 p.m. ET on Gameday Audio
Scott Merkin is a reporter for MLB.com. Read his blog, Merk's Works, and follow him on Twitter @scottmerkin. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.